I’ve spent a lot of time lately in rooms full of smart, experienced people trying to make difficult decisions.
These aren’t situations where there’s an obvious “right” answer and someone just needs to point it out. The people around the table may represent different organizations, functions, communities, or constituencies. They have different information, different responsibilities, and different risks to manage.
And often, they’re all right about at least something.
That’s what makes these decisions hard.
It’s tempting to think the solution is to get everyone in a room, put the issue on the agenda, and talk it through. But in my experience, that’s rarely enough.
The work starts before the meeting.
Before facilitating a complex decision, I want to understand the landscape.
- What has already happened?
- Where has the conversation gotten stuck?
- What information does the group have… or need?
- What are people worried about?
- What interests and constraints are shaping their positions?
That might involve interviews, surveys, background materials, conversations with subject-matter experts, or all of the above.
Then comes agenda design. Not simply: What should we talk about?
But also: What does this group need to understand, wrestle with, and decide—and in what order?
That sequence matters.
Is this an information problem or an alignment problem?
This is one of the most useful distinctions I’ve found.
Sometimes people disagree because they’re working from different information. One person knows something another doesn’t. People interpret the same data differently. Or an important factual question hasn’t been answered. That’s an information problem.
Other times, everyone understands the facts perfectly well and still disagrees. They value different outcomes. They have different tolerances for risk. A solution that benefits one stakeholder creates a burden for another. That’s an alignment problem.
You can close an information gap with data, expertise, or analysis.
You can’t data-crunch your way out of a genuine difference in interests.
Put the competing interests on the table.
When people represent different organizations or constituencies, it’s easy for disagreement to become “us versus them.”
Instead, I try to make the underlying interests visible.
- What are we trying to protect?
- What risks are we trying to avoid?
- What outcomes matter most?
- What constraints are real?
That changes the conversation. Instead of defending camps, the group can begin wrestling together with the actual tradeoffs.
And once the tradeoffs are visible, you can give the disagreement some structure. You can separate tangled questions, test people’s assumptions, establish criteria, identify what the group already agrees on, and isolate what actually remains unresolved.
Don’t manufacture consensus.
Sometimes everyone agrees. Sometimes they don’t.
A facilitator’s job isn’t to make disagreement disappear.
There are times when an excellent outcome is:
- We agree on these three things.
- We disagree on this one.
- Here is the decision we made anyway.
Or:
- We aren’t ready to decide.
- These two questions need answers first, and here is how we’re going to get them.
A successful session doesn’t necessarily end with everyone getting the outcome they wanted. It ends with people understanding what was decided, what remains unresolved, and what happens next.
Sometimes consensus is the outcome. And when that happens? Fantastic.
But my ultimate goal, as facilitator, is to drive clarity and forward movement.