I manage a recurring team meeting for one of my clients, whom I support as fractional chief of staff. Here’s a fun and useful agenda item that we’ve been including in those meetings, which has been helpful for boosting trust, transparency, and accountability. I call it “Gold Stars & Demerits,” and it was inspired by a similar feature on the Happier podcast, which is cohosted by Gretchen Rubin and Elizabeth Craft.
How it works
During each meeting, I will say something like:
- Okay, now it’s time for Gold Stars and Demerits! I’ll go first.
- I’m giving a gold star to myself for reorganizing our project deck, because it took a lot of time, but it’s already making things easier on this team.
- And I’m giving a gold star to Roger, for reminding me about that enablement event next week. I completely blanked on that, and you saved several folks on this team from a last minute scramble!
- I’m giving a demerit to myself, for forgetting that we’ve already locked in our priorities for this quarter, and going directly to your team, Magda, to ask them to take on something new.
- Does anyone else have a gold star or demerit to issue this week?
Why it works
Gold stars provide an opportunity to celebrate your own wins, in an easy and playful way, so people feel appreciated and understood. Gold stars also empower peers to express gratitude to each other, which builds a cohesive team that naturally comes together during difficult moments–rather than pulling apart.
Demerits help individuals model humility, discuss regrets or growth moments, and hold themselves accountable for not living up to their commitments or standards. They also give people a safe space to air small grievances–and engage in productive conflict–rather than let those fester into resentment.
Tips and tricks
It’s best to keep the tone light, but also real. There’s a delicate balance, you won’t always get it right, and that’s okay. Modeling humility and good humor goes a long way.
Most of the time, though, this portion of the agenda brings a few knowing chuckles, a sense of appreciation for the enormous amount of work the team is leading, and renewed trust that everyone is working toward a common purpose.
Watch closely for passive aggression, defensiveness, or other unhealthy team dynamics, and nip these in the bud… while also keeping the environment safe.
Occasionally, we have to press pause on something that emerges and add it to the “Ad Hoc” section of our agenda, or agree on how and when to continue that conversation. It’s best to allow enough time for some chatter and discussion, but not allow a gold star or demerit to derail the meeting agenda, nor let something uncomfortable drop without any path toward resolution.
Try it out
If you decide to try this meeting agenda item, give the team at least 3 meetings to get comfortable, before deciding whether to make it a regular part of your team meetings. And let me know how it goes!
